Dave Cameron at FanGraphs has discovered something fascinating. Breaking down the number of men to play in the major leagues and the number of Hall of Famers by their birth year, he found that HOF electors have been remarkably consistent in the percentage of players they elect—roughly one percent to two percent of those born each decade. Except for those born in the '60s, who are currently sitting at 0.1 percent. Only two ballplayers born from 1961-1970 are currently in Cooperstown: Roberto Alomar and Barry Larkin. That number will rise, of course, but even with the remarkably stacked ballots of the next few years, there's no possible way the decade will produce the 30 to 50 Hall of Famers required to put it near previous levels. The problem is obviously not with the players' ages, but with their era. Being born in the '60s means a player's prime was somewhere from the late 1980s to the early 2000s, exactly the period many BBWAA members would like to pretend never existed. But as Cameron's numbers illustrate, voters have painted themselves into a corner. If potential Hall members should be judged against those they played against, there shouldn't be any dip in induction rates. But if they ought to be judged against baseball history as a whole, a dip of this magnitude is statistically unlikely unless it's the voters that are the problem. The only conclusion is that voters' HOF standards, whether due to perceptions of steroid-fueled numbers or expansion or anything at all, are currently the most stringent in the Hall's history, and it's going to punish some of the best players from one of baseball's golden ages. By any measure, that's a shame. The Hall of Fame's Standard, and Its Biggest Problem [FanGraphs]
Related Posts
Stevan Jovetic wants to please Inter s fans by taking three points from the Derby d Italia clash with Juventus on Sunday.
Roberto Mancini s team were knocked off top spot in Serie A by Fiorentina in the previous round of fixtures but still hold an eight-point advantage over their Turin-based rivals.
Montenegro international Jovetic who has been struggling with a hamstring injury in recent weeks does not believe the defending champions are enduring a crisis but hopes to add to their woes at San Siro.
Physically, I m fine and I ll be ready to play. We will have to be careful as they are a good team and I do not trust those who talk of a crisis, Jovetic told Tuttosport.
The fans want us to win against Juventus and we want to please them.
The 25-ye…
Saido Berahino has been sent to undergo specialist training in France in an attempt to get fit, West Brom head coach Tony Pulis confirmed.
The former England Under-21 international has only played four times in the Premier League this season, with the forward struggling for fitness and unable to improve his form from last term when he scored just four goals in 31 appearances.
Berahino has endured a difficult time since reportedly becoming distracted by transfer speculation at the end of the 2014-15 campaign, and now finds himself sent away for an intensive four-day boot camp in France.
And Pulis is optimistic that Berahino will return a much sharper player.
Saido s off at the moment in a fitness centre, working with a fella that I worked with when I was …
Hansi Flick was delighted to see Germany show their enormous quality as they hammered Armenia 6-0, though Serge Gnabry felt the victory could have been more emphatic.
Germany moved to the top of World Cup qualifying Group J in style in Flick s first home game in charge on Sunday.
Gnabry scored twice in the first 15 minutes before goals from Marco Reus and Timo Werner put the game beyond all doubt by half-time.
Jonas Hofmann and debutant Karim Adeyemi rounded off a rout that thrilled head coach Flick, who was quick to urge his side to stay focused ahead of Wednesday s clash with Iceland.
I liked this game but on Wednesday we still have a game in Iceland, so the team can be happy with their performance but we have to stay focused, Flick told RTL.
…
Frenkie de Jong always wanted to stay at Barcelona despite heavy interest from Manchester United during the transfer window.
Netherlands international De Jong was the subject of a long-running saga, with the midfielder s former Ajax boss Erik ten Hag reportedly desperate to build his new-look United side around him.
A move looked likely after it was suggested De Jong was owed €17million in deferred wages and had been asked to sign a new contract with a salary reduction of around 40 per cent.
The switch never materialised, though, with United instead signing Casemiro from Real Madrid in a bid to strengthen their midfield.
This was Barça s starting eleven at the Reale Arena for matchday two in the league.
It s an historical line-up. Do yo…
Lyon say that in-demand playmaker Yoann Gourcuff will still be at the club once the transfer window has closed.
Gourcuff, 27, is thought to be a transfer target of Arsenal, while La Liga sides Atletico Madrid and Valencia have also been linked with a move for the former Bordeaux man.
The France international battled injury last season and made just 18 Ligue 1 appearances, scoring three goals.
But despite the fact he has failed to replicate his form he showed at Bordeaux since moving for €22 million in 2010, Lyon are still keen to keep him at the Stade de Gerland.
Lyon presidential advisor Bernard Lacombe told OL TV: Yoann Gourcuff won t leave during this transfer window. The president told me that there were opportunities, but all three parties need to be in ag…
Will signing Nemaja Matic prove to be a masterstroke from Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho?
Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho has brought one player in and shipped two players in the January transfer window so far, but the moves are being questioned by some.
Serbian international midfielder Nemanja Matic has returned to the club from Benfica in a deal worth a reported fee of £20million.
Belgium winger Kevin De Bruyne has joined Bundesliga club Wolfsburg in a deal worth £16million, while left-back Ryan Bertrand has joined Aston Villa on-loan for the rest of the season.
Returned
Re-signing Matic was a strange one for some though.
The 25-year-old left Stamford Bridge in 2011 in search of first football after failing to establish himself in the Chelsea …
Newly promoted Parma will start the new season on a level footing with the rest of Serie A after a five-point penalty was overturned and replaced with a fine.
The sanction was originally imposed in July by the Italian Football Federation (FIGC) after they concluded Parma forward Emanuele Calaio sent suspicious messages to Spezia players last term.
Calaio – who used to play for Spezia – was found to have communicated with former team-mates Filippo De Col and Claudio Terzi ahead of the Serie B fixture between the teams at the end of the 2017-18 season.
In the FIGC s case document, which named both De Col and Terzi, it accused Calaio of trying to get less commitment from the players of Spezia . Parma won the game 2-0 to secure a third successive promotion.
…
Lautaro Martinez s stunning volley secured Inter a 1-0 victory over Atletico Madrid in the final match of the International Champions Cup.
Forward Martinez scored the only goal of the game in the 31st minute against the club he nearly joined last year, acrobatically putting away Kwadwo Asamoah s cross-field ball to stun the home side at the Wanda Metropolitano.
The Argentine forward signed by Inter from Racing Club in July also demonstrated his blossoming partnership with Mauro Icardi early in the first half, sending his compatriot through on goal in the 11th minute.
Jan Oblak rushed from his line to smother Icardi’s chipped attempt on that occasion, but the Atletico goalkeeper could do little to prevent the game s eye-catching winner just after the half…
A confident Jose Mourinho said he will need only two years to win the Champions League with Real Madrid after he was officially unveiled as the Spanish giants new coach on Monday.
Mourinho joined Real on a four-year deal in the wake of leading Inter Milan to an historic treble of successes in Italy s Serie A championship, the Italian Cup and Champions League.
And after replacing Manuel Pellegrini, sacked last week after a barren season having spent 250 million euros on new players including Cristiano Ronaldo, Kaka and Xabi Alonso, Mourinho feels he can do far better than the 56-year-old Chilean.
The second year is key, it is the year when you find the right balance. It was during my second year at Chelsea that we reached the Champions League final. It was durin…
Sheffield Wednesday’s appeal to find Lee Gregory’s face mask has been successful with the club confirming it is back in safe hands ahead of their Sky Bet League One play-off final.
Gregory lost his protective mask during the Owls’ celebrations following their stunning fightback against Peterborough at Hillsborough in Thursday’s semi-final.
Darren Moore’s side overcame a 4-0 first-leg deficit to win 5-1 on the night after extra time and 5-3 in a penalty shoot-out, sparking wild scenes of joy among players and fans, who invaded the pitch.
Can you help!?
In the aftermath of our stunning comeback win on Thursday, Lee Gregory’s mask is missing!
The custom-built protective cover was near the dugout. Due to a short turnaround, we cannot repla…